[andrewsfm]

Hmmm, so I think I'm going to go with colour matching the entire thing. Leaving the bit of chrome sounded like a good idea but now that I can see it, it still looks out of place.

As for the lights, not quite what I meant. I'm debating between having the chrome part not tinted at all, just the red like the Photoshop you did, or if I should also do the chrome part, except a cutout for the reverse bulb.